Learn More >
or
Close X
It looks like you have JavaScript disabled.
For the best experience, please enable JavaScript.
or
It looks like you have JavaScript disabled and you’re using an outdated browser, which PJM no longer supports.
For the best experience, please enable JavaScript and upgrade to a modern browser.
or
Sign In
Tools Sign In
Search
Communities
Member Community
Planning Community
Membership Management Community
Calendar
Toggle navigation
about pjm
training
committees
&
groups
planning
markets
&
operations
library
about pjm
training
committees
&
groups
planning
markets
&
operations
library
Committees
&
Groups
Meeting Center
Critical Issue Fast Path - Resource Adequacy
Committees
Audit Advisory Committee
Finance Committee
Budget Process
&
Finance Committee Recommendations
Financial Reporting
PJM Administrative Cost Rates
PJM Settlement Administrative Cost Rates
Pass-Through Rates
Liaison Committee
Market Implementation Committee
Market Monitoring Unit – Advisory Committee
Markets and Reliability Committee
Members Committee
Nominating Committee
Operating Committee
Planning Committee
Risk Management Committee
Subregional RTEP Committee - Mid-Atlantic
Subregional RTEP Committee - Southern
Subregional RTEP Committee - Western
Transmission Expansion Advisory Committee
Transmission Owners Agreement-Administrative Committee
User Groups
Public Interest
&
Environmental Organizations User Group
Forums
eDART Forum
Tech Change Forum
Emerging Technologies Forum
Nuclear Generation Owner Forum
Stakeholder Process Forum
Subcommittees
Cost Development Subcommittee
Station Service Rates
Handy Whitman Index
Data Management Subcommittee
Distributed Resources Subcommittee
Designated Entity Design Standards Subcommittee
Dispatcher Training Subcommittee
Electric Gas Coordination Subcommittee
Governing Document Enhancement
&
Clarification Subcommittee
Interconnection Process Subcommittee
Load Analysis Subcommittee
Market Settlements Subcommittee
Relay Subcommittee
Relay Testing Subcommittee
Reliability Standards
&
Compliance Subcommittee
Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee
System Operations Subcommittee
TO/TOP Matrix Subcommittee
Transmission
&
Substation Subcommittee
Task Forces
ARR FTR Market Task Force
Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
Deactivation Enhancements Senior Task Force
Effective Load Carrying Capability Senior Task Force
Modeling Generation Senior Task Force
Reserve Certainty Senior Task Force
Regulation Market Design Senior Task Force
Resource Adequacy Senior Task Force
Workshops
Long-Term Regional Transmission Planning Workshop
Closed Groups
Pandemic Coordination
Reactive Power Compensation Task Force
Issue Tracking
Stakeholder Meetings
Inter-Regional Planning Stakeholder Advisory Committee - MISO
Annual Meeting of Members
General Session
Price Formation Education Sessions
DER Ride-Through Workshop
GO15 Governing Board Meeting
Inter-Regional Planning Stakeholder Advisory Committee - New York / New England
PJM/MISO Joint
&
Common Market Initiative
PJM/NYISO Joint Initiative
State Commissions
Independent State Agencies Committee
Webex
&
Microsoft Teams
Home
Committees
&
Groups
Issue Tracking
Issue Details
Issue Details
ARR/FTR Market Review
The ARR FTR Market Task Force (AFMTF) will conduct a comprehensive review of the ARR/FTR market design including allocation of congestion rights, FERC objectives, value proposition, and opportunities for enhancements.
Proposed Timeline
Issue initiated: 10.16.2019
Work begins: 1.13.2020
Target Completion: 1.31.2021
Actual Completion: TBD
Issue Details
Stakeholder Body
ARR FTR Market Task Force
Facilitator
Anders, David
Subject Matter Expert
Chmielewski, Brian
MIC Approval Date
10.6.2021
MRC Approval Date
10.20.2021
Problem Statement/
Issue Charge First Read
9.11.2019
Issue Catalyst
Dominion Energy, Exelon, NextEra Power Marketing, PSEG Energy Resources & Trade, Dynegy Marketing & Trade, Vitol, and the Financial Marketers Coalition.
Issue Status
On-Hold
Manual Changes
No
Issue Charge
PDF
Stakeholder Process Step
Approved
Education
Interest
Design
Options
Packages
Consensus
Review
Completed
Associated Materials
Governing Documents
2.21.2023 - MC Information Webinar
Item 06B - MIC Report
PDF
4.25.2022 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
3.21.2022 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
2.9.2022 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 10 - Annual Update
PDF
1.26.2022 - MRC
Consent Agenda A - Draft Minutes - MRC - 12.15.2021
PDF
1.24.2022 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
1.12.2022 - MIC
Draft Minutes - MIC - 12.9.2021
PDF
1.11.2022 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 10.20.2021
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 3 - Potential Survey
PDF
Item 4 - Summary & Next Steps
PDF
12.15.2021 - MRC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Consent Agenda A - Draft Minutes - MRC - 11.17.2021
PDF
Consent Agenda B - Manual 6 Revisions - Presentation
PDF
Consent Agenda B - Manual 6 Revisions - Executive Summary
PDF
Consent Agenda B - Manual 6 Revisions - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda B - Manual 6 Revisions - Clean
PDF
12.1.2021 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Draft Minutes - MIC - 11.3.2021
PDF
Item 3A - ARR/FTR Market Review - Manual 06 - Revisions - Presentation
PDF
Item 3B - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 06 Revisions - Redline
PDF
Item 3C - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 06 Revisions - Clean
PDF
Item 3D - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 06 Revisions - Executive Summary
PDF
11.17.2021 - MC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Consent Agenda E - AFMTF Presentation
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 5.2 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.1 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.1A - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.3 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.4 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.5 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.6 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OATT Attachment K Appendix Section 7.8 - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - OA Zonal Base Load Definition - Redline
PDF
Consent Agenda E - IMM ARR FTR Proposal - Presentation
PDF
11.17.2021 - MRC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Consent Agenda A - Draft Minutes 10.20.2021
PDF
Item 8A - Manual 6 Revisions - Presentation
PDF
Item 8A - Manual 6 Revision - Executive Summary
PDF
Item 8A - Manual 6 Revisions - Redline
PDF
Item 8A - Manual 6 Revision - Clean
PDF
11.3.2021 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Minutes
PDF
Draft Minutes - MIC - 10.6.2021
PDF
Item 4B - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 6 - Revision 28 - Presentation
PDF
Item 4B - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 6 - Revision 28 - Redline
PDF
Item 4C - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 6 - Revision 28 - Clean
PDF
Item 4D - ARR FTR Market Review - Manual 6 - Revision 28 - Executive Summary
PDF
10.20.2021 - MRC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
10.18.2021 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Item 8D - ARR/FTR Market Review Report
PDF
10.6.2021 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Minutes
PDF
Draft Minutes - MIC - 9.9.2021
PDF
Item 2A - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update PJM Joint Stakeholder Proposal
PDF
Item 2B - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update IMM Proposal
PDF
Item 2C - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update DC OPC Proposal
PDF
Item 2D - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update - AEP Proposal
PDF
Item 2E - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update Matrix
XLS
9.9.2021 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Minutes
PDF
Item 8A - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update - Presentation
PDF
Item 8B - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update - IMM - Proposal
PDF
Item 8C - ARR/TFR Market Task Force Update - DC OPC - Proposal
PDF
Item 8D - ARR/FTR Market Task Force Update - Matrix
XLS
6.25.2021 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 6.11.2021
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 3 - Presentation
PDF
Item 4 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
Item 5 - IMM Market Design Notes Update
PDF
6.21.2021 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 11J - AFMTF Report - June
PDF
Item 11J - AFMTF Report - May
PDF
6.11.2021 - ARR/FTR Market Task Force
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 5.24.2021
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 3 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
Item 4 - ARR/FTR Solution Options Follow Up
PDF
Item 5 - ARR/FTR Market Design & Design Components - IMM Proposals
PDF
Item 6 - FTR Forfeiture Rule Update
PDF
5.24.2021 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 4.26.2021
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 3 - LEI Presentation
PDF
Item 4 - May Presentation
PDF
Item 5 - DC Energy - Presentation
PDF
Item 6 - IMM Market Design
PDF
Item 7 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
4.26.2021 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 3.25.2021
PDF
Item 3 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 4 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
Item 5 - ARR/FTR Design Considerations
PDF
4.19.2021 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 12H - AFMTF Report
PDF
3.25.2021 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF 2.23.2021
PDF
Item 3 - FTR Survey
PDF
Item 4 - March Presentation
PDF
Item 5 - FTR Capability
PDF
Item 6 - IMM Self Scheduling ARR as Offset
PDF
3.22.2021 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
2.23.2021 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 1.26.2021
PDF
Item 1 - Dominion Energy Comments on LEI Analysis
PDF
Item 2 - Exelon Perspective on LEI Report & Next Steps
PDF
Item 3 - Additional ARR Enhancements
PDF
Item 4 - FTR LEI - DCE Comments
PDF
Item 5 - IMM LEI Discussion
PDF
Item 6 - FTR ARR Presentation
PDF
Workshop Survey
PDF
2.22.2021 - MC Information Webinar
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
9.2.2020 - MIC
Draft Minutes - MIC - 8.5.2020
PDF
8.5.2020 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Item 3 - Hiatus Recommendation
PDF
7.22.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 6.26.2020
PDF
Item 2 - Poll Results
PDF
Item 3 - Congestion by Constraint Two Settlement
PDF
Item 3A - Constraint Based Congestion Calculations
PDF
Item 3B - 12 Bus Base Impedance & DFAX - Post Meeting
XLS
6.26.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 5.27.2020
PDF
Item 2A - Review Scope of Work
PDF
5.27.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 4.29.2020
PDF
Item 2A - FTR Review - Initial Scope
PDF
Item 2B - Work Plan
PDF
Item 2C - Post Meeting Comments
PDF
Item 3A - Issues & Next Steps
PDF
Item 3B - Congestion
PDF
Item 4 - Load Serving Entities - Perspective on AFMTF Design
PDF
Item 5 - Congestion Rents & cLMP
PDF
Item 6 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
4.29.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 3.25.2020
PDF
Item 2 - Issue Charge - Approved
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 2 - Comparison of Congestion Hedging Markets & Auction Revenue Allocations
XLS
Item 2 - Comparison of Congestion Hedging Markets & Auction Revenue Allocations - Post Meeting
XLS
Item 3 - IARR Education
PDF
Item 4 - FTR Market Review Whitepaper Overview
PDF
Item 5 - ARRs & FTRs
PDF
Item 6 - Response to PJM
PDF
Item 7 - ARR Allocation & Cross Subsidies
PDF
Item 8 - Analysis of PJM ARR FTR Market Design & Reform Options
PDF
Item 8 - CAPS Brief PJM FTR Design Review
PDF
Item 8 - Options for Reforming ARR FTR Market Design
PDF
Item 9 - Options & Packages Matrix
XLS
4.15.2020 - MIC
Agenda
PDF
Item 6 - AFMTF Status
PDF
3.25.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 2.19.2020
PDF
Item 2 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 5 - FTR PTP Construct
PDF
Item 6 - Existing FTR Construct Education - Part 2
PDF
Item 7 - PJM Bill & Congestion Paid
PDF
Item 8 - CAISO CRR Market Overview
PDF
Item 9 - ERCOT Congestion Revenue Rights Market Overview
PDF
2.19.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 1 - Draft Minutes - AFMTF - 1.13.2020
PDF
Item 3 - ARR/FTR Offset & Price Convergence
PDF
Item 4 - Existing FTR Construct Education
PDF
1.13.2020 - AFMTF
Agenda
PDF
Agenda
DOC
Item 2 - Issue Charge
PDF
Item 3 - Work Plan
PDF
Item 4 - History & Evolution of FTRs in PJM
PDF
Item 5 - FTR History
PDF
View All